Administrative and Substance Review of the Proposal on SGP Indonesia Cycle I

/in /by

The Call for Proposal of Small Grants Program (SGP) Grant Proposal in Indonesia was announced on 15 September 2019 and the proposal that was submitted was assessed through two (2) stages, namely: the first stage, an administrative assessment carried out by the Penabulu Foundation as a Service Provider on the 4th October 2019 for Way Kambas National Park and 7 October for Gunung Leuser National Park. The second stage, the substance assessment on 15-16 October 2019, based on the results of the administrative evaluation there were four (4) proposals for Way Kambas National Park and eight (8) proposals for Gunung Leuser National Park conducted by the Regional Program Coordination Unit of the Small Grant Program ASEAN Centre for Biodiversity and the National Working Team of the SGP Indonesia (National Working Team) which took place at the Santika Hotel, Slipi, Jakarta.

The National Work Team (NWT) was attended by nine (9) people and the RPCU SGP ACB was attended by six (6) people and the assessment process was led directly by Ms. Nining Purnamaningtyas as Chair of the National Working Team. The proposal assessment uses an instrument mutually agreed between NWT and ACB. Each work team conducts an assessment of proposals that pass the administrative assessment from the first assessment agreement to mutually understand the process and the way the assessment will be carried out.

The assessment process takes a long time and considers several aspects of both the text and the context and needs of national parks as beneficiaries in AHP protection. After the plenary meeting, it was agreed to recall several proponents deemed necessary to obtain clarification of the proposed proposal, and agreed to summon several proponents to clarify the proposal submitted on October 21, 2019 at Manggala Wanabhakti, Ministry of Environment and Forestry, Jakarta.

On the agenda of clarifying the proposal of SGP Indonesia Cycle 1 at Cafe Mangarove was attended by seven (7) people from the NWT Team (National Working Team) and three (3) people from the Penabulu Foundation as Service Providers. The assessment process was led directly by Ms. Nining Purnamaningtyas as Chair of the National Working Team on October 21, 2019 there were seven (7) proponents from Way Kambas National Park and Gunung Leuser National Park. In the clarification, the NWT provided input and recommendations for the proponent to revise the proposed proposal.

The revision deadline is set for October 25, 2019 at 11:59 p.m. WIB, the proponent making the revision must have sent the revision of the NWT input to the Penabulu Foundation as a Service Provider, and compile the results of the revision to be immediately sent to the NWT for re-evaluation.

The proposal assessment by NWT was carried out on October 28, 2019 at the Ibis Slipi Hotel in Jakarta, which was attended by 7 people from the NWT Team (National Working Team) and 5 people from the Penabulu Foundation as a Service Provider. The assessment process was led directly by Ms. Nining Purnamaningtyas as Chair of the National Working Team and took place democratically by prioritizing agreed themes, regional contexts, and national park needs. The assessment results are summarized and sent by the NWT / KKH KLHK to ACB, which are then averaged as the final results. Endorsement from the National Steering Committee (NSC) will be the final stage of evaluating the SGP Indonesia Cycle 1 proposal.

Penilaian Administrasi dan Substansi Review Proposal Hibah Kecil SGP Indonesia Siklus I

/in /by

Panggilan Proposal Hibah Small Grants Program (SGP) di Indonesia telah diumumkan pada 15 September 2019 dan proposal yang telah diajukan, dilakukan penilaian melalui dua (2) tahap, yaitu: tahap pertama, penilaian administrasi yang dilakukan oleh Yayasan Penabulu sebagai Service Provider pada tanggal 4 Oktober 2019 untuk Taman Nasional Way Kambas dan 7 Oktober untuk Taman Nasional Gunung Leuser. Tahap kedua, penilaian substansi pada tanggal 15 – 16 Oktober 2019, berdasarkan hasil penilaian secara administrasi ada empat (4) proposal untuk Taman Nasional Way Kambas dan delapan (8) proposal untuk Taman Nasional Gunung Leuser yang dilakukan oleh Unit Koordinasi Program Regional Program Hibah Kecil atau Regional Programme Coordination Unit (RPCU) Small Grant Program dan Tim Kerja Nasional SGP Indonesia (National Working Team) yang berlangsung di Hotel Santika, Slipi, Jakarta.

Tim Kerja Nasional (NWT) dihadiri oleh sembilan (9) orang dan RPCU SGP ACB dihadiri oleh enam (6) orang dan proses penilaian dipimpin langsung oleh Ibu Nining Purnamaningtyas selaku Ketua National Working Team. Penilaian Proposal menggunakan instrumen yang disepakati bersama antara NWT dan ACB. Masing-masing tim kerja melakukan penilaian atas proposal yang lolos penilaian administrasi dari kesepakatan penilaian pertama untuk saling memahami porses dan cara penilaian yang akan dilakukan.

Proses penilaian berjalan dengan lama serta mempertimbangkan beberapa aspek baik teks maupun konteks serta kebutuhan taman nasional sebagai penerima manfaat dalam perlindungan AHP. Setelah melakukan pleno, disepakati untuk memanggil kembali beberapa proponen yang dianggap perlu mendapatkan klarifikasi atas proposal yang diusulkan, dan disepakati memanggil beberapa proponent untuk mengklarifikasi proposal yang diajukan pada tanggal 21 Oktober 2019 di Manggala Wanabhakti, KLHK, Jakarta.

Pada agenda klarifikasi proposal SGP indonesia Siklus 1 di Cafe Mangarove dihadiri oleh tujuh (7) orang dari Tim NWT (National Working Team) dan 3 orang dari Yayasan Penabulu sebagai Service Provider. Proses penilaian yang dipimpin langsung oleh Ibu Nining Purnamaningtyas selaku Ketua National Working Team pada tanggal 21 Oktober 2019 terdapat tujuh (7) proponen dari Taman Nasional Way Kambas dan Taman Nasional Gunung Leuser. Dalam klarifikasi tersebut NWT memberikan masukan dan rekomendasi untuk proponen  agar melakukan revisi atas proposal yang diusulkan tersebut.

Batas waktu revisi ditentukan tanggal 25 Oktober 2019 pukul 23.59 WIB, proponen yang melakukan revisi harus telah mengirimkan revisi dari masukan NWT ke Yayasan Penabulu sebagai Service Provider, dan mengkompilasi hasil revisi untuk segera dikirmkan ke NWT untuk dilakukan penilaian kembali.

Penilaian Proposal oleh NWT dilakukan pada tanggal 28 Oktober 2019 di Hotel Ibis Slipi Jakarta,yang dihadiri oleh 7 orang dari Tim NWT (National Working Team) dan 5 orang dari Yayasan Penabulu sebagai Service Provider. Proses penilaian dipimpin langsung oleh Ibu Nining Purnamaningtyas selaku Ketua National Working Team dan berlangsung demokratis dengan mengedepankan tema yang disepakati, konteks wilayah, dan kebutuhan taman nasional. Hasil Penilaian dirangkum dan dikirimkan oleh NWT/KKH KLHK ke ACB, yang kemudian hasil penilaian direrata sebagai hasil akhir. Dukungan dari National Steering Commitee (NSC) menjadi tahapan akhir penilaian proposal SGP Indonesia Siklus 1.